Let's dive into the intriguing world of Hollywood and uncover a story that sheds light on the complexities of movie-making.
The Unexpected Meeting of Two TV Icons
In the late 1950s, long before Alan Hale Jr. became the beloved Captain Jonas Grumby on "Gilligan's Island," he was already making waves in the industry. His collaboration with James Garner on the World War II submarine drama "Up Periscope" is a fascinating glimpse into the dynamics of Hollywood.
A Star's Contempt
What makes this particularly fascinating is the stark contrast in the actors' experiences. Hale Jr., it seems, thoroughly enjoyed his time on the set, while Garner, on the other hand, couldn't have been more disinterested. In fact, Garner's contempt for the movie is well-documented. In his memoir, "The Garner Files: A Memoir," co-written with Jon Winokur, Garner gave the movie a scathing one-star review, calling it "another piece of crap" he was forced to do while under contract.
The Director's Perspective
Gordon Douglas, the director of "Up Periscope," had an impressive filmography by the time he took on this project. His previous work includes the groundbreaking sci-fi film "Them!" (1954). However, Garner's harsh critique suggests that "Up Periscope" might not have lived up to the director's previous successes.
Critical Reception
A. H. Weiler of the New York Times offered a somewhat mixed review, acknowledging the film's lack of dramatic flair but praising the cast and crew for their dedication. Interestingly, Weiler singled out Hale Jr. for his ability to bring levity to the film, a skill he would later showcase on "Gilligan's Island."
A Deeper Look
This story raises a deeper question about the nature of artistic collaboration. While Hale Jr. seemed to thrive in the environment, Garner's experience highlights the potential challenges of working on projects that may not align with an actor's personal tastes or artistic vision.
In conclusion, the tale of "Up Periscope" serves as a reminder that even in the world of Hollywood, where stars and directors often collaborate, the experience can vary greatly from person to person. It's a fascinating insight into the subjective nature of art and the complex dynamics that shape the entertainment industry.
